The House has had 435 seats since 1913

What if the House had kept growing?

A state's Electoral College votes come from its House seats. Replay every presidential election since 1912 with a bigger House and see whether the winner changes.

The short answer

  • Cube root: 1 of 29 elections would have had a different outcome (2000).
  • Wyoming rule: no change in any of the 29 elections.
YearReal HouseCube rootWyoming rule
Wilson 435/531Wilson 446/547Wilson 1010/1237
Wilson 277/531Wilson 287/547Wilson 632/1237
Harding 404/531Harding 415/547Harding 935/1237
Coolidge 382/531Coolidge 409/568Coolidge 1065/1484
Hoover 444/531Hoover 476/568Hoover 1247/1484
Roosevelt 472/531Roosevelt 527/592Roosevelt 1346/1509
Roosevelt 523/531Roosevelt 583/592Roosevelt 1492/1509
Roosevelt 449/531Roosevelt 501/592Roosevelt 1288/1509
Roosevelt 432/531Roosevelt 491/604Roosevelt 1051/1284
Truman 304/531Truman 346/604Truman 731/1284
Eisenhower 442/531Eisenhower 522/627Eisenhower 862/1032
Eisenhower 457/531Eisenhower 539/627Eisenhower 889/1032
Kennedy 303/537Kennedy 360/632Kennedy 737/1270
Johnson 486/538Johnson 603/666Johnson 809/893
Nixon 302/538Nixon 370/666Nixon 495/893
Nixon 521/538Nixon 671/692Nixon 750/774
Carter 297/538Carter 386/692Carter 434/774
Reagan 489/538Reagan 632/692Reagan 706/774
Reagan 525/538Reagan 696/712Reagan 652/667
Bush 426/538Bush 565/712Bush 531/667
Clinton 370/538Clinton 507/732Clinton 448/649
Clinton 379/538Clinton 521/732Clinton 460/649
Bush 271/538Gore 368/732changedBush 325/649
Bush 286/538Bush 397/758Bush 352/671
Obama 365/538Obama 519/758Obama 458/671
Obama 332/538Obama 485/779Obama 401/647
Trump 306/538Trump 442/779Trump 367/647
Biden 306/538Biden 445/779Biden 369/647
Trump 312/538Trump 462/795Trump 393/676

Electoral votes count faithless electors for the candidate they were pledged to (for example Trump 306 in 2016, though 304 were cast).

Explore 2024

Same outcome: Donald Trump still wins.

  • Trump462real House: 312
  • Harris333real House: 226

House of 692 (real: 435) · 795 electors · 398 to win · 2020 census

Alabama: 13 electoral votes (actual 9), TrumpAlaska: 4 electoral votes (actual 3), TrumpArizona: 17 electoral votes (actual 11), TrumpColorado: 14 electoral votes (actual 10), HarrisFlorida: 47 electoral votes (actual 30), TrumpGeorgia: 24 electoral votes (actual 16), TrumpIndiana: 16 electoral votes (actual 11), TrumpKansas: 8 electoral votes (actual 6), TrumpMaine: 5 electoral votes (actual 4), HarrisMassachusetts: 17 electoral votes (actual 11), HarrisMinnesota: 14 electoral votes (actual 10), HarrisNew Jersey: 21 electoral votes (actual 14), HarrisNorth Carolina: 24 electoral votes (actual 16), TrumpNorth Dakota: 4 electoral votes (actual 3), TrumpOklahoma: 10 electoral votes (actual 7), TrumpPennsylvania: 29 electoral votes (actual 19), TrumpSouth Dakota: 4 electoral votes (actual 3), TrumpTexas: 63 electoral votes (actual 40), TrumpWyoming: 3 electoral votes (actual 3), TrumpConnecticut: 10 electoral votes (actual 7), HarrisMissouri: 15 electoral votes (actual 10), TrumpWest Virginia: 6 electoral votes (actual 4), TrumpIllinois: 29 electoral votes (actual 19), HarrisNew Mexico: 6 electoral votes (actual 5), HarrisArkansas: 8 electoral votes (actual 6), TrumpCalifornia: 85 electoral votes (actual 54), HarrisDelaware: 4 electoral votes (actual 3), HarrisDistrict of Columbia: 3 electoral votes (actual 3), HarrisHawaii: 5 electoral votes (actual 4), HarrisIowa: 9 electoral votes (actual 6), TrumpKentucky: 11 electoral votes (actual 8), TrumpMaryland: 15 electoral votes (actual 10), HarrisMichigan: 23 electoral votes (actual 15), TrumpMississippi: 8 electoral votes (actual 6), TrumpMontana: 4 electoral votes (actual 4), TrumpNew Hampshire: 5 electoral votes (actual 4), HarrisNew York: 44 electoral votes (actual 28), HarrisOhio: 27 electoral votes (actual 17), TrumpOregon: 11 electoral votes (actual 8), HarrisTennessee: 16 electoral votes (actual 11), TrumpUtah: 9 electoral votes (actual 6), TrumpVirginia: 20 electoral votes (actual 13), HarrisWashington: 18 electoral votes (actual 12), HarrisWisconsin: 14 electoral votes (actual 10), TrumpNebraska: 6 electoral votes (actual 5), TrumpSouth Carolina: 13 electoral votes (actual 9), TrumpIdaho: 6 electoral votes (actual 4), TrumpNevada: 9 electoral votes (actual 6), TrumpVermont: 3 electoral votes (actual 3), HarrisLouisiana: 12 electoral votes (actual 8), TrumpRhode Island: 4 electoral votes (actual 4), Harris
All 50 states and DC: seats and electoral votes
StateSeatsElectors (real)Electors hereGoes to
Alabama11913Trump 13
Alaska234Trump 4
Arizona151117Trump 17
Arkansas668Trump 8
California835485Harris 85
Colorado121014Harris 14
Connecticut8710Harris 10
Delaware234Harris 4
District of Columbia—33Harris 3
Florida453047Trump 47
Georgia221624Trump 24
Hawaii345Harris 5
Idaho446Trump 6
Illinois271929Harris 29
Indiana141116Trump 16
Iowa769Trump 9
Kansas668Trump 8
Kentucky9811Trump 11
Louisiana10812Trump 12
Maine345Harris 4Trump 1
Maryland131015Harris 15
Massachusetts151117Harris 17
Michigan211523Trump 23
Minnesota121014Harris 14
Mississippi668Trump 8
Missouri131015Trump 15
Montana244Trump 4
Nebraska456Trump 5Harris 1
Nevada769Trump 9
New Hampshire345Harris 5
New Jersey191421Harris 21
New Mexico456Harris 6
New York422844Harris 44
North Carolina221624Trump 24
North Dakota234Trump 4
Ohio251727Trump 27
Oklahoma8710Trump 10
Oregon9811Harris 11
Pennsylvania271929Trump 29
Rhode Island244Harris 4
South Carolina11913Trump 13
South Dakota234Trump 4
Tennessee141116Trump 16
Texas614063Trump 63
Utah769Trump 9
Vermont133Harris 3
Virginia181320Harris 20
Washington161218Harris 18
West Virginia446Trump 6
Wisconsin121014Trump 14
Wyoming133Trump 3

Flip finder: 2024

Every House size from 100 to 2000, using the apportionment method and split-state option above.

45%50%59%100435100015002000435692
Line: Trump's share of electoral votes as the House grows from 100 to 2000 seats. Background: who wins at that size.
  1. 100–2000 seats: Trump

How this works

In the Electoral College, each state gets one elector per House seat plus two for its senators. The House grew after almost every census until the 1911 Apportionment Act set it at 433 (435 once Arizona and New Mexico joined). After the 1920 census Congress never reapportioned, and the 1929 Act made 435 permanent. Every election since 1912 has been run on a 435-seat House (437 in 1960, after Alaska and Hawaii joined).

House size rules

Cube root rule
House size ≈ the cube root of the population, the pattern most national legislatures follow (692 seats after 2020).
Wyoming rule
Every district is about the size of the least populous state.
People per representative
A fixed ratio, like the Constitution's original floor of 30,000.
Fixed / custom
Pick one size, or a size after each census.

Assumptions

  • Votes are held fixed: everyone votes exactly as they did. Real campaigns would adapt.
  • Counterfactual Houses are reapportioned after every census, including 1920 (which was skipped in reality), using the selected method. Huntington–Hill has been the law only since 1941.
  • Maine and Nebraska: two electors go to the statewide winner, and district electors are scaled from the real district split. This is an estimate, since more districts would be drawn differently.
  • Faithless electors are returned to the candidate they were pledged to. Historically split delegations (e.g. California 1912, Alabama 1960) are scaled proportionally, or given to the popular-vote winner if you choose that option.
  • DC (from 1964) gets as many electors as it would as a state, capped at the smallest state.
  • If nobody wins a majority, the House would choose, with one vote per state delegation. The site doesn't simulate that vote.

References

Data sources and licenses are listed in data/SOURCES.md. The code is MIT licensed and open source on GitHub.