The 1928 election

Hoover vs. Smith: what if it had been run with different rules?

Same outcome: Herbert Hoover still wins.

  • Hoover476actual electors: 444
  • Smith92actual electors: 87

House of 472 (real: 435) · 568 electoral votes · 285 to win · 1920 census

Map

Alabama: 13 electoral votes (actual 12): Smith 13Alaska: not a state in 1928Arizona: 3 electoral votes (actual 3): Hoover 3Colorado: 6 electoral votes (actual 6): Hoover 6Florida: 6 electoral votes (actual 6): Hoover 6Georgia: 15 electoral votes (actual 14): Smith 15Indiana: 15 electoral votes (actual 15): Hoover 15Kansas: 10 electoral votes (actual 10): Hoover 10Maine: 5 electoral votes (actual 6): Hoover 5Massachusetts: 19 electoral votes (actual 18): Smith 19Minnesota: 13 electoral votes (actual 12): Hoover 13New Jersey: 16 electoral votes (actual 14): Hoover 16North Carolina: 13 electoral votes (actual 12): Hoover 13North Dakota: 5 electoral votes (actual 5): Hoover 5Oklahoma: 11 electoral votes (actual 10): Hoover 11Pennsylvania: 41 electoral votes (actual 38): Hoover 41South Dakota: 5 electoral votes (actual 5): Hoover 5Texas: 23 electoral votes (actual 20): Hoover 23Wyoming: 3 electoral votes (actual 3): Hoover 3Connecticut: 8 electoral votes (actual 7): Hoover 8Missouri: 17 electoral votes (actual 18): Hoover 17West Virginia: 9 electoral votes (actual 8): Hoover 9Illinois: 31 electoral votes (actual 29): Hoover 31New Mexico: 4 electoral votes (actual 3): Hoover 4Arkansas: 10 electoral votes (actual 9): Smith 10California: 17 electoral votes (actual 13): Hoover 17Delaware: 3 electoral votes (actual 3): Hoover 3District of Columbia: not a state in 1928Hawaii: not a state in 1928Iowa: 13 electoral votes (actual 13): Hoover 13Kentucky: 13 electoral votes (actual 13): Hoover 13Maryland: 9 electoral votes (actual 8): Hoover 9Michigan: 18 electoral votes (actual 15): Hoover 18Mississippi: 10 electoral votes (actual 10): Smith 10Montana: 4 electoral votes (actual 4): Hoover 4New Hampshire: 4 electoral votes (actual 4): Hoover 4New York: 48 electoral votes (actual 45): Hoover 48Ohio: 28 electoral votes (actual 24): Hoover 28Oregon: 6 electoral votes (actual 5): Hoover 6Tennessee: 12 electoral votes (actual 12): Hoover 12Utah: 4 electoral votes (actual 4): Hoover 4Virginia: 12 electoral votes (actual 12): Hoover 12Washington: 8 electoral votes (actual 7): Hoover 8Wisconsin: 14 electoral votes (actual 13): Hoover 14Nebraska: 8 electoral votes (actual 8): Hoover 8South Carolina: 10 electoral votes (actual 9): Smith 10Idaho: 4 electoral votes (actual 4): Hoover 4Nevada: 3 electoral votes (actual 3): Hoover 3Vermont: 4 electoral votes (actual 4): Hoover 4Louisiana: 10 electoral votes (actual 10): Smith 10Rhode Island: 5 electoral votes (actual 5): Smith 5
All 48 states: seats and electoral votes
StateSeatsElectors (real)Electors hereGoes to
Alabama111213Smith 13
Arizona133Hoover 3
Arkansas8910Smith 10
California151317Hoover 17
Colorado466Hoover 6
Connecticut678Hoover 8
Delaware133Hoover 3
Florida466Hoover 6
Georgia131415Smith 15
Idaho244Hoover 4
Illinois292931Hoover 31
Indiana131515Hoover 15
Iowa111313Hoover 13
Kansas81010Hoover 10
Kentucky111313Hoover 13
Louisiana81010Smith 10
Maine365Hoover 5
Maryland789Hoover 9
Massachusetts171819Smith 19
Michigan161518Hoover 18
Minnesota111213Hoover 13
Mississippi81010Smith 10
Missouri151817Hoover 17
Montana244Hoover 4
Nebraska688Hoover 8
Nevada133Hoover 3
New Hampshire244Hoover 4
New Jersey141416Hoover 16
New Mexico234Hoover 4
New York464548Hoover 48
North Carolina111213Hoover 13
North Dakota355Hoover 5
Ohio262428Hoover 28
Oklahoma91011Hoover 11
Oregon456Hoover 6
Pennsylvania393841Hoover 41
Rhode Island355Smith 5
South Carolina8910Smith 10
South Dakota355Hoover 5
Tennessee101212Hoover 12
Texas212023Hoover 23
Utah244Hoover 4
Vermont244Hoover 4
Virginia101212Hoover 12
Washington678Hoover 8
West Virginia789Hoover 9
Wisconsin121314Hoover 14
Wyoming133Hoover 3

Flip finder

Every House size from 100 to 2000, with the rest of your rules.

45%50%85%100435100015002000435472
Line: Hoover's share of electoral votes as the House grows from 100 to 2000 seats. Background: who wins at that size.
  1. 100–2000 seats: Hoover