What if we voted differently?

Every election under real proposals to change how electors are awarded, with the real House. Open an election to see its map, or pick a method in its rules.

  • Popular vote: 2 of 29 elections would have had a different outcome (2000, 2016).
  • Proportional: 7 of 29 elections would have had a different outcome (1912, 1948, 1960, 1968, 1992, 2000, 2016).
  • Fractional: 1 of 29 elections would have had a different outcome (2016).
  • District-style: 4 of 29 elections would have had a different outcome (1960, 1968, 1992, 2016).
  • Bonus: 2 of 29 elections would have had a different outcome (2000, 2016).
  • Ranked choice: no change in any of the 29 elections.
YearTodayPopular voteProportionalFractionalDistrict-styleBonusRanked choice
1912Wilson 435/531Wilson 41.9%No majority changedWilson 246.6/531Wilson 288/531Wilson 537/633Wilson 433/531
1916Wilson 277/531Wilson 49.2%Wilson 291/531Wilson 283.8/531Wilson 296/531Wilson 379/633Wilson 276/531
1920Harding 404/531Harding 60.3%Harding 305/531Harding 294.8/531Harding 316/531Harding 506/633Harding 404/531
1924Coolidge 382/531Coolidge 54.0%Coolidge 266/531Coolidge 258.5/531Coolidge 289/531Coolidge 484/633Coolidge 382/531
1928Hoover 444/531Hoover 58.2%Hoover 299/531Hoover 294.6/531Hoover 323/531Hoover 546/633Hoover 444/531
1932Roosevelt 472/531Roosevelt 57.4%Roosevelt 334/531Roosevelt 327.6/531Roosevelt 354/531Roosevelt 574/633Roosevelt 472/531
1936Roosevelt 523/531Roosevelt 60.8%Roosevelt 349/531Roosevelt 342.9/531Roosevelt 371/531Roosevelt 625/633Roosevelt 523/531
1940Roosevelt 449/531Roosevelt 54.7%Roosevelt 315/531Roosevelt 313/531Roosevelt 336/531Roosevelt 551/633Roosevelt 449/531
1944Roosevelt 432/531Roosevelt 53.4%Roosevelt 300/531Roosevelt 301.5/531Roosevelt 317/531Roosevelt 534/633Roosevelt 432/531
1948Truman 304/531Truman 49.6%No majority changedTruman 258.2/531Truman 269/531Truman 406/633Truman 304/531
1952Eisenhower 442/531Eisenhower 55.2%Eisenhower 291/531Eisenhower 288.7/531Eisenhower 314/531Eisenhower 544/633Eisenhower 442/531
1956Eisenhower 457/531Eisenhower 57.4%Eisenhower 296/531Eisenhower 296.6/531Eisenhower 323/531Eisenhower 559/633Eisenhower 457/531
1960Kennedy 303/537Kennedy 49.5%No majority changedKennedy 263.8/537No majority changedKennedy 405/639Kennedy 298/537
1964Johnson 486/538Johnson 61.1%Johnson 320/538Johnson 320.1/538Johnson 348/538Johnson 588/640Johnson 486/538
1968Nixon 302/538Nixon 43.4%No majority changedNixon 231.6/538No majority changedNixon 404/640Nixon 302/538
1972Nixon 521/538Nixon 60.7%Nixon 337/538Nixon 330.5/538Nixon 369/538Nixon 623/640Nixon 521/538
1976Carter 297/538Carter 50.1%Carter 273/538Carter 269.8/538Carter 270/538Carter 399/640Carter 297/538
1980Reagan 489/538Reagan 50.7%Reagan 285/538Reagan 272.9/538Reagan 312/538Reagan 591/640Reagan 489/538
1984Reagan 525/538Reagan 58.8%Reagan 323/538Reagan 317.6/538Reagan 352/538Reagan 627/640Reagan 525/538
1988Bush 426/538Bush 53.4%Bush 291/538Bush 287.8/538Bush 316/538Bush 528/640Bush 426/538
1992Clinton 370/538Clinton 43.0%No majority changedClinton 230.5/538No majority changedClinton 472/640Clinton 370/538
1996Clinton 379/538Clinton 49.2%Clinton 273/538Clinton 263.7/538Clinton 277/538Clinton 481/640Clinton 379/538
2000Bush 271/538Gore 48.4%changedNo majority changedBush 259.2/538Bush 272/538Gore 369/640changedBush 271/538
2004Bush 286/538Bush 50.7%Bush 278/538Bush 274.6/538Bush 286/538Bush 388/640Bush 286/538
2008Obama 365/538Obama 52.9%Obama 289/538Obama 283.4/538Obama 292/538Obama 467/640Obama 365/538
2012Obama 332/538Obama 51.1%Obama 275/538Obama 272.2/538Obama 279/538Obama 434/640Obama 332/538
2016Trump 306/538Clinton 48.2%changedNo majority changedClinton 256.2/538changedNo majority changedClinton 334/640changedTrump 306/538
2020Biden 306/538Biden 51.3%Biden 273/538Biden 273.3/538Biden 278/538Biden 408/640Biden 306/538
2024Trump 312/538Trump 49.8%Trump 272/538Trump 269.3/538Trump 282/538Trump 414/640Trump 312/538

The methods

Winner-take-all (today)
Each state's popular-vote winner takes all of its electors (Maine and Nebraska split theirs by congressional district). A majority of electors wins; otherwise the House picks.
National popular vote
The most votes nationwide wins. The National Popular Vote Interstate Compact does this once states with 270 electoral votes join (18 states and DC with 222 so far). The Bayh–Celler amendment (1969) would have done it directly; it passed the House 339–70 and died in a Senate filibuster. Its 40% runoff threshold was never needed: every winner since 1912 had more. National Popular Vote: state status. Bayh–Celler amendment (Wikipedia).
Proportional electors (Colorado 2004)
Colorado Amendment 36 (rejected 65–35 in 2004): each ticket gets its share of the state's electors rounded to the nearest whole number. Over-allocations come off the smallest ticket that has an elector; any shortfall goes to the leader. A majority of electors is still needed, so close three-way races go to the House. Colorado 2004 ballot information booklet (full text). 2004 Colorado Amendment 36 (Wikipedia).
Fractional electors (Lodge–Gossett 1950)
The Lodge–Gossett amendment (S.J.Res. 2) passed the Senate 64–27 in 1950 and failed in the House. Electors are abolished: each candidate gets their exact share of each state's electoral votes, to three decimal places, and the most electoral votes wins, with no majority needed. National Popular Vote memo on Lodge–Gossett (PDF).
Statewide winner +2, rest proportional
An estimate of the Maine (since 1972) and Nebraska (since 1992) district method used everywhere: the statewide winner gets the two Senate electors. District results aren't available for most years, and a bigger House would redraw every district, so the House electors are split in proportion to the statewide vote instead. Pennsylvania's SB 538 (2013) proposed exactly this split; it died in committee. Maine statute 21-A §805. Nebraska statute 32-714. Pennsylvania proportional plan memo (2012).
National Bonus Plan (1978)
Proposed by the Twentieth Century Fund task force and introduced by Sen. Birch Bayh (S.J.Res. 123, 1978): today's system plus 102 bonus electors (two per state and DC) for the national popular-vote winner. A majority of all electors still wins. Every Vote Equal, chapter 4 (PDF). S.J.Res. 123 (95th Congress).
Ranked choice in each state (Maine 2020)
Each state runs an instant runoff, as Maine has since 2020 and Alaska since 2024. Real ballots weren't ranked, so you choose where each eliminated candidate's voters go next. With an even split, no election changes. Maine P.L. 2019, c. 539 (PDF). Alaska Ballot Measure 2 (2020), Ballotpedia.